IP vs analog cameras compared for homes and businesses
How IP and HD analog cameras differ in cabling, power, resolution and analytics, and when analog is still the better buy.
6 min read

In the IP vs analog debate, a new building almost always ends up with IP cameras. An IP camera compresses its own video, takes power and sends data over a single network cable, and IP models offer a much wider choice of resolutions and analytics. HD analog wins in one common situation: the building already has coaxial cable and a working DVR, and you want a sharper picture without rewiring.
How the picture reaches the recorder
An HD analog camera sends video as an analog signal over coaxial cable. The DVR (digital video recorder) digitises and compresses it, and every camera needs its own cable run back to the DVR. Power usually comes from a separate supply, from the extra cores of a combined cable or, where the equipment supports it, over the coax itself.
An IP camera works like a small computer with a lens. It encodes video in H.264 or H.265 and sends it over the network to an NVR (network video recorder). The cable is twisted pair, the same as a computer network uses. If the camera supports PoE, the same cable carries its power. The camera plugs into the nearest network switch, so the cable does not have to run all the way to the recorder.
HD analog comes in several formats that do not work with each other directly: AHD, HD-TVI and HD-CVI. The camera and the DVR have to share a format. Many current recorders accept all three, but check the specification before you buy.
IP and analog cameras side by side
| Parameter | HD analog cameras | IP cameras |
|---|---|---|
| Cable | Coaxial, a separate run from each camera to the DVR | Twisted pair to the nearest switch, fibre or a wireless bridge for long distances |
| Power | Separate power supply or a combined cable | PoE over the same cable as the video |
| Cable length | Hundreds of metres over coax, depending on the format and the cable | Up to 100 m from the switch, beyond that another switch, an extender or fibre |
| Recorder | DVR or hybrid XVR | NVR |
| Resolution | Usually 2–8 MP | From 2 MP to 8 MP and above, including panoramic and multi-sensor models |
| Analytics | Mostly in the recorder, on some channels | In the camera and the recorder: line crossing, zone entry, telling people from vehicles |
| Adding a camera | A new run to the DVR and a free channel on it | A cable to the nearest switch and a free channel on the NVR |
Existing cabling usually decides the choice
In an occupied building, running cable is the hardest part of the installation. It means getting through ceilings and walls, hiding the runs in trunking or chased channels and then making good the finish. That is why the first question on a site survey is what wiring is already there and what state it is in.
If the coaxial runs are sound, swapping old cameras for HD analog models with a new DVR gives Full HD or better without any building work. If twisted pair is already in place, or the building is still under construction, the cabling work is the same either way, and IP wins on everything else. There is also a middle route. Ethernet over Coax adapters carry an IP camera's network signal over the old coax, and some models carry power too.
Where IP cameras are stronger
- Reading a number plate at the gate or recognising a face at the till takes high resolution and the right lens. The IP range has more of these models, including cameras with a motorised zoom.
- A camera with analytics sends an alert when a person or a vehicle crosses a line you draw. Plain motion detection also fires on shadows, leaves and insects near the lens, and within a week nobody reads the alerts.
- With PoE a camera needs no socket nearby, and all the cameras can run from one UPS in the equipment cabinet.
- Some IP cameras have a memory card slot and keep recording to the card if the link to the NVR drops.
- A new camera in the far corner of a warehouse connects to a nearby switch instead of a dedicated cable across the whole building.
When HD analog is still a sensible choice
Analog makes sense when an old coaxial system needs a better picture with as little disruption to the finish as possible. It also suits a small site with four to eight cameras where the owner wants a simple setup with no network configuration. The cameras plug into the DVR, and the DVR connects to the router for viewing on a phone.
If some cameras need IP features, a hybrid recorder (XVR) takes analog cameras plus a limited number of IP cameras. That lets you move to IP gradually, room by room as renovation allows. Our article NVR or DVR covers the recorders in more detail.
Decide these before you buy
- Which cable is already in place, and whether new cable can go in without damaging the finish.
- What each camera must show on the recording: a silhouette, a face or a number plate. That sets the resolution and the lens.
- How many cameras you may add in the next couple of years. An IP system is easier to extend.
- Whether you want alerts on your phone. Without analytics there will be too many of them.
- How many days of recordings to keep. That sets the number and size of the hard drives in the recorder.
How we choose cameras on site
A LAGI engineer visits the site, checks the existing wiring, the lighting and the spots where detail matters, and only then recommends IP, analog or a hybrid. Site surveys in Tbilisi are free. We then prepare the CCTV system design, showing where each camera goes and what it covers, and carry out the CCTV installation, including viewing on your phone. You can browse the models in our catalog first, under IP cameras and HD analog cameras. To describe your site, use the quote request form.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, IP or analog cameras?
For a new system, IP cameras are better. They take power and send video over one cable, offer more resolution options and can tell a person from a car. HD analog cameras are the better buy when coaxial cable is already installed and a DVR is working. New cameras then improve the picture without rewiring or redecorating.
Can I connect an IP camera to a standard DVR?
No. A standard DVR only accepts an analog signal. IP cameras connect to an NVR or to a hybrid XVR recorder with IP channels. A hybrid recorder lets you keep working analog cameras and add IP ones over time. The number of IP channels is limited and is listed in the specification.
Can old coaxial cable be reused for IP cameras?
Yes, with Ethernet over Coax adapters, one pair per cable run. Some adapters also carry camera power over the coax. This is worth doing when the cable is intact and new twisted pair would mean opening up walls or ceilings. Before buying adapters, the run is tested for breaks and signal loss.
Do IP cameras record without internet?
Yes. IP cameras record to the NVR over the local network. The internet is only needed for viewing on a phone and for alerts. If the connection drops, recording to the NVR continues. Cameras with a memory card slot keep recording even if the link to the recorder itself is lost.