Skip to content

NVR or DVR? Choosing the right recorder for your cameras

A DVR records analog cameras and an NVR records IP cameras. How to size a recorder by channels, disks, PoE and analytics, and when a hybrid XVR fits.

6 min read

Video recorder with its lid open showing two drives, connected to three cameras, under an archive timeline

Your cameras settle the NVR or DVR question. A DVR records HD analog cameras connected by coaxial cable, and an NVR records IP cameras connected over the network. If the cameras are already installed, the recorder type is effectively chosen. For a new system, choose the cameras first and then size the recorder to their number, their resolution and how long you need to keep recordings.

What a video recorder does

The recorder takes video from the cameras, writes it to hard drives and shows live and recorded footage on a monitor, a computer or a phone app. It also sends event alerts, stores the camera settings and gives different users different access rights. The recorder is also where you search footage by time or event and export a clip to a USB stick.

How a DVR differs from an NVR

A DVR receives an analog signal from each camera, then digitises and compresses it itself. Each camera plugs into its own BNC socket on the back panel, so the number of cameras is limited by the number of inputs: 4, 8, 16 or 32.

An NVR receives a stream that the IP camera has already compressed. Cameras connect over the network, and the recorder can sit anywhere on it. The limits are the number of channels and the incoming bandwidth, given in megabits per second. A 16-channel recorder might, for example, accept 160 Mbit/s across all cameras.

ParameterDVRNVR
CamerasHD analog (AHD, HD-TVI, HD-CVI)IP cameras
ConnectionCoax, a separate input for each cameraNetwork: built-in PoE ports or an external switch
Where video is compressedIn the recorderIn the camera, the recorder stores the finished stream
What limits the camera countNumber of BNC inputsNumber of channels and incoming bandwidth in Mbit/s
Camera powerSeparate power supplyPoE from the recorder or a switch
AnalyticsOn some channels, done by the recorderIn the cameras and in the recorder
LocationWhere the coaxial runs meetAnywhere on the local network

A hybrid XVR for a mixed system

A hybrid recorder (XVR, called HVR by some makers) takes analog cameras on BNC inputs plus a few IP cameras over the network. It fits when old analog cameras still work and you want new points to be IP. A hybrid usually has fewer IP channels than a full NVR, so it is the wrong choice for a large new system. Our article IP vs analog cameras covers choosing the cameras themselves.

How many channels to buy

Count the cameras you are installing now and add the ones that may follow: a camera for a new gate, a second storeroom, another till. An 8-channel recorder with seven channels taken on day one will feel cramped within a year. When the channels run out, the whole recorder has to be replaced, so build in the spare capacity from the start.

How to size the disks for your archive

Archive size depends on the cameras' bitrate, the recording mode and the number of days you keep. Bitrate is the amount of data a camera sends each second. A 4 MP camera using H.265 typically runs at 3–4 Mbit/s, depending on the scene and the settings.

For continuous recording, the bitrate in Mbit/s × 86,400 seconds ÷ 8 gives megabytes per day. A camera streaming 4 Mbit/s records about 43 GB a day, or roughly 1.3 TB over 30 days. Eight such cameras fill about 10 TB in a month.

Recording on motion or on analytics events cuts the volume sharply where little happens for most of the day, such as a warehouse at night. This mode needs careful detection settings, or the moment you need may not be recorded. For a large archive, choose a recorder with two or four drive bays, and on models with four to eight bays turn on RAID so that one failed drive does not wipe the recordings. Use drives rated for round-the-clock surveillance work.

Built-in PoE or a separate switch

Many NVRs have built-in PoE ports. A camera plugs straight into the recorder and takes its power over the same cable, which is convenient for a small system because everything sits in one cabinet. There are two limits. Each camera's cable runs all the way to the recorder and must not exceed 100 m. The PoE ports also share a total power budget, which needs checking if there are many cameras or some of them are PTZ models or have strong infrared illumination.

When cameras are spread over a large site, separate PoE switches go near each group of cameras. Our article what is PoE explains how PoE works and how to calculate a power budget.

What else to check in the specification

  • Incoming bandwidth in Mbit/s. Add up the bitrates of all cameras and leave room for future ones.
  • Decoding. A recorder may record 8 MP cameras yet display only a limited number of such streams at once. That matters if a guard watches every camera on one screen.
  • Compatibility. Cameras and a recorder from the same maker support every feature. Other brands connect over ONVIF, and some analytics may not work.
  • Monitor outputs, HDMI or VGA, and their resolution.
  • The mobile app. Make sure the maker supports and updates it.

How we choose a recorder

At LAGI we choose the recorder once the cameras are settled. We count channels with spare capacity, work out the archive and the bandwidth, and decide whether built-in PoE is enough. Models with full specifications are in our catalog under NVR and DVR. If you already have a system and are unsure whether it records and the disks are healthy, start with CCTV maintenance. For a new system, send a quote request. Site surveys in Tbilisi are free.

Frequently asked questions

Do IP cameras need a recorder?

For a system of several cameras, yes. An IP camera can record to a memory card or the cloud, but a card holds little and disappears if the camera is stolen, and the cloud depends on the internet and a paid subscription. An NVR keeps every camera's archive in one place on large drives and finds footage quickly by time or event.

How many days of footage does a recorder keep?

As many as fit on its drives. When space runs out, the recorder overwrites the oldest footage. A camera streaming 4 Mbit/s uses about 43 GB a day, so eight such cameras on 8 TB of disks keep roughly 23 days of continuous recording.

What is an XVR and how is it different from a DVR?

An XVR is a hybrid recorder. Like a DVR, it accepts HD analog cameras in several formats, and it also connects a few IP cameras over the network. A standard DVR works only with analog cameras. An XVR is the choice when analog cameras stay in the system and new points are IP.

Where should the recorder be installed?

In a locked cabinet or a back room that strangers cannot reach, with ventilation and a UPS. A recorder on display by the till is easy to carry off along with the recordings. Where theft is a real risk, the archive is copied to the cloud or to a second recorder in another room.

Want an engineer to look at your property?

Book a site survey: we will inspect the property and prepare a quote.